What is there to say about the Shderot I visited two weeks ago? This is not occupied territory. This is not disputed territory. It’s a provincial town with 25,000 inhabitants, with a fire station big enough to serve 50,000. In the past seven years, it’s been the target of over 6,000 rockets from Gaza, and the rate of shelling has escalated since Israel ceased to occupy Gaza.
Shderot means avenues – its streets are wide and crossing one to take cover in the air raid shelters which have replaced bus stops can take longer than the 17-second air raid warning.
Most of Shderot’s children and adults suffer from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. Its teenagers don’t feel able to go to school. The younger children go, but now walk past a five-foot concrete facade before they see the school windows; the building receives no natural light; their voices are stopped up in their schools.
I see five year olds rush out at going-home time. The school guards says,
Where is there for you to go? Stay back and wait for your parents.
He only says it once. The children remembered quickly and drew back against the wall until they are bussed away or pulled into cars by parents who look so 21st Century that it’s impossible to believe their situation, their dull eyes, their wooden movements, their grey skin, their lack of gestural animation.
I see two youths in a playground smoking under a concrete gazebo. Ah, I think, rebels. But they’re guards.
All over Israel the ban on smoking inside buildings is observed. But in Schderot’s tired town hall, everyone is smoking. George, a Council employee, takes me to the police station and shows me a yard stacked with the detritus of homemade kassam missiles. These are made from sliced sections of hollow Israeli traffic-light poles, smuggled to Gaza in tunnels by Bedouin. Each Gazan hamoula group designs and paints the Kassams it fires at Israel. Now they are just stacked pipes splayed like peeled bananas. Pipes with sharp tail fins. Pipes five-foot long. Cardboard boxes full of metal fragments, metal nails, off cuts of the shards which women stuff these pipes with. Each stacked item is labelled with white markings. Date, time, location picked up.
Schderot’s bus stops all stand in rows, as though waiting to march back to the streets once the barrages end.
There’s dismay in Schderot at their own government’s restraint. Confusion at the world’s failure to intervene. Why are civilians bombed day and night, as schools discharge their pupils, as the town tries to do work or sleep?
In Burger Ranch, a group of young professionals eat and laugh quietly, talk like young people anywhere. They look so different to the despondent people I’ve seen so far.
Who are you, do you live here, everyone looks so depressed why do you look different? I ask.
We’re from the area; we work at Amdocs here in Schderot. Why wouldn’t we? You don’t just stop in real life, they answer.
The graffiti in Schderot says, ‘Wake up Ariel Sharon, Olmert is sleeping’ and ‘Our state you have abandoned us in war’. The parents have rushed the children home. The streets are expressionless. The shops wait for the thousands of people who flood in from all over Israel on Fridays to support Schderot’s beleaguered economy by buying their groceries for the Sabbath. Residents who have somewhere to go have left. Their houses are unsellable. The ones who stay have no choice. They’re not idealists. Not the frontline. Not Israel’s Dodge City. They’re just unregistered victims. Unregistered in the Israeli psyche. People have forgotten the constant bombardment of Kiryat Shmona. Israeli Jews, Arabs and Christians bombed during Lebanon 2 in August 2006 don’t even understand the Gazan onslaught which has lasted seven years. The national debate centres on withdrawal from the West Bank and people on both sides of the argument ignore Schderot. The Friday shoppers are mainly the moderate modern orthodox men wearing jeans and crocheted skull caps and women wearing head kerchiefs (if they’re married). They are given to measures on the micro scale. Prayer not politics, shopping not shouting. They don’t form themselves into power groups. They’ve organised a rally in Tel Aviv’s Rabin Square with but no widespread action across Israel.
Schderot has lived with this ignominy for long enough to build a trauma centre for its children, long enough to fortify its schools, long enough for its teenagers to have lost hope, long enough to have crushed its idealists, long enough to extinguish the inclination of even one mayoral candidate to run for office against the incumbent when he wanted to resign, and long enough to suspend the Israel’s watchfulness over its own. But not long enough to destroy the young Amdocs employees steady resolve to take up employment.
If the range of Hamas’s missiles extend, will the industries of Ashkelon, Eilat and Tel Aviv be able to retain that sort of resolve?
I am Palestinian/English living in Jerusalem, and I could tell you many a story of trauma. If I could get into Gaza and write all the number of people who have suffered from post traumatic stress it would overload the small town of Sderot.
I shouldn’t be commenting on this article, but more on your previous one, which shocked me as a human being. You were trying to find excuses and loop holes out of something which was a shame to humanity. I do not approve of the rockets, but you seemed to be attempting to make the rockets into something ‘special’ or out of the norm. You have no idea what its like for so many in this country, living in far worse scenarios than those in Sderot, with no air raid shelters and no alarm to warn you of impending rockets.
There isn’t even an attempt to understand why these rockets may be coming over into Sderot.
Hamas won the election in Gaza as they were a break from Fatah. Fatah who had signed the Oslo accords and promised to crack down — arrest, torture any violent resistance. Many Gazans believe that violent resistance is a way to end the occupation, siege they are under and attain some basis of minimum human rights. There is an uncomfortable balance in international law surrounding the matter. It is legal to resist occupation by any means necessary, but it is illegal to attack civilian targets. Gazans are not the only group of people to use violence to achieve political ends. Britain has in Iraq, Germany in Afghanistan, Israel holds a military occupation over Palestinians.
Hamas also violently resist as a machismo stance to gain popular support with little regard for the safety of their civilians. However, they have also on numerous occasions offered a ten-year ceasefire to Israel as a basis for starting negotiations. (1) They also observed a 6 month ceasefire with Israel prior to the assault on Gaza, until Israel broke that ceasefire by killing six alleged militants on November 4th, Israel itself admits this. (2)
Israel makes incursions into Gaza on almost a daily basis and bombs targets regularly killing innocent Gazans. (3) This was last night. (4) Israelis have an option to leave Sderot, Gazans do not have that option. (5)
What is going on in Shderot and Gaza is a disgrace. It has to be solved by immediate talks with no preconditions. It cannot be solved with borders decided by race. There has to be the goal of no borders with citizenship not depending upon race. I firmly believe that if this option were offered Gazans would grasp it with both hands. Hamas through their offers of ceasefires have showed they are willing to negotiate. They accept the idea of a two-state solution. (6) Remember 80% of Gazans are refugees of the ’48 war, they do not want to be there and under constant Israeli bombardment as much as the people of Shderot want to be there under attack from Gaza. With the two places being only a mile apart surely a resolution can be found and respected.
(1) http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/nov/01/israel
(2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SILJxPTqjAM
(3) http://www.maannews.net/eng/ViewDetails.aspx?ID=241073
(4) http://www.arabnews.com/?page=4§ion=0&article=129991&d=22&m=12&y=2009
(5) http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/767510.html
(6) http://edition.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/meast/04/04/mideast/index.html
This is irresponsible journalism. And with so much of this stuff clogging up the corporate-owned news media, I thought there might have been some original (or at least accurate!) comment here. In her ‘factual’ work, Ms. Green appears to practice propaganda by omission and distortion – using the very same methods that FIPA states it is counteracting! Drivel, emotive and infantalising, petty sloganry. Sound familiar, FIPA?